Board Thread:VS Debates/@comment-25182985-20151203014150/@comment-25263388-20160204010719

Let's just go off the basis of Modern Hulk aka Doc Green.

Doc Green - still powered up by rage, but with a lot of intellect too, and the kind of healing factor that means he can fight a living nuke and then do science half a minute later, only getting stronger, faster and more durable the longer the fight goes on, tries to outwit his opponents and play to their weaknesses. Strongest one there is, Smartest one there is, Most tactical one there is, he's everything but fastest. He took down A-Bomb, the Leader, the Gamma Pack, Red Hulk, Red She-Hulk, She-Hulk, Skaar and a ton of gamma villains. Has fought the likes of the U-Foes, the Avengers and the X-Men.

Broly - Super-speed, two ultimate forms unlocked by anger, and a fighting style based around busting planets and a combat methodology of angering your opponent. Energy attacks that can destroy planets.

BROLY

+ Insanely faster

+ More radical power increases

+ Energy attacks give greater versatility

+ More powerful when the two start off

- His style of angering another opponent would likely work REALLY badly for him

- While he has a lot of experience, most of his opponents are exactly the same, none like Hulk, and very few who are intelligent

- Has a penchant for underestimating enemies meaning he lost twice to Goku

- No healing factor means any injury is permanent without rest to heal

- Though he could destroy the planet, he can't breathe in space (no Saiyan can) and Hulk can regenerate from dying from not being able to breathe in space (which makes no sense but lol)

HULK

+ Much more intelligent

+ Constantly increasing strength, speed and healing factor

+ Would likely be able to heal back from any major attack of Broly's if it didn't kill him, even one causing the loss of arms or legs

+ His tactical mastery would allow him to bait Broly, in his Saiyan battle lust, to draw out the battle long enough for Hulk to become fast enough to beat Broly

- Nowhere near as fast as Broly, and although he could eventually get that fast, he would likely be dead by the time he got that angry

- Unlikely to be able to dodge Broly's strongest attacks, which are all energy-based

- No ranged attacks to counter Broly's ki

Broly wins if it's short and sweet, Hulk wins in a long run. This is like Sonic vs Flash, Sonic wins an OMM because he gets stronger faster, but Flash wins in the Death Battle because he's just plain OP.