Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-31270269-20170313181642/@comment-16919137-20171228230426

Also, now that this season is done, let's see what I disagree with here:

Scrooge VS Shovel Knight- Controversial fight is controversial. My main issue here is that Shovel Knight's physicality feats were pretty much ignored, while Scrooge got some of his more impressive feats. I agree that physical strength would go to Scrooge, but Destructive Capacity is a category that Shovel Knight owns quite handily via scaling to the Enchantress' City level storm feat and Black Knight's meteor. Shovel Knight reacting to the Black Knight's meteors and the Phantom Striker's lightning gives him the speed advantage as well. Also, something they failed to consider is that Shovel Knight's blade can reflect projectiles, which possibly include the Neutral Friction and Anti-Inertia ray. Lastly, Shovel Knight wields the Alchemy Coin, which exploits Scrooge's main weakness: incredible greed. It also turns him into a pile of gold coins, so not much he could do there.

Sub-Zero VS Glacius- Not gonna act like I know a whole ton about Glacius, but, from what I've seen, he possesses the physicality advantage in spades (ESPECIALLY in terms of speed) and I've heard his cryomancy is better.

Balrog VS TJ Combo- Again, not gonna act like I know a whole ton about TJ, but, from my research, Balrog just gets far too much scaling to characters in terms of speed and DC for TJ to be much of a threat (In particular, the argument for Balrog scaling to Ryu can actually be mentioned).

Silver Samurai VS Shredder- Not gonna act like I expected them to get this right, but Silver Samurai gets tons of scaling from characters like Wolverine, Spider-Man, and possibly even Luke Cage (At least in terms of durability), which would allow him to trounce even Super Shredder in physicality. Also, the Tachyon Blade is basically a free one-shot tool. Shredder cannot parry or counter the blade without getting bisected.

Batman Beyond VS Spider-Man 2099- Oh god, did they hit Miguel with a nerf stick. All of his best feats/scaling were pretty much ignored. Also, there is a massive inconsistency in the analysis: They ranked a partially-symbioted Eddie Brock as a 200 tonner, but they wouldn't rank 2099 as such despite the obvious scaling (A fully-symbioted Eddie would be stronger, sure, but a partially-symbioted should be on-par).