Talk:Scrooge McDuck VS Shovel Knight/@comment-2255534-20170222064330

So in light of the recent comment chain of Tracer vs Scout, I feel like I need to give my two cents of a bothering topic. Not the fight itself, but a topic that's been on my mind that I feel promotes arrogance of the worst kind: A fight being right or wrong.

First, a small eminder of something about me that some of you already know. Of the 72 episodes of Death Battle, I completely supported the outcome of every single fight. To me, every character, especially the oens I particularly know well, were represented very well and I've almost always been satisfied with their reasoning.

Now does that mean that I think everyone who thinks otherwise is wrong? Not nessicarily.

Another suble secret of mine is that I hate Cartoon Fight Club, which is like the anti-Death Battle to me. I've never been fully satisfied with the outcomes or reasoning. But, when you compare CFC's Hulk vs Doomsday to Death Battle, should you expect me to call CFC wrong?

That's the genuine secret: I have NEVER, nor will I ever at any point, even if it's a fight I don't agree with, say that Animation Rewind was wrong for believing the concluded outcome. He was merely looking at all of those fights from his perspective, and has even been changed that perspective sometimes. It's ALL perspective.

So to take the thread below as an example, if you think Scout would win and the fight was wrong, or if Tracer would win and the fight was right, maybe you're the one who's wrong. We all agree that everyone should have their opinion, but because fictional fights are so subjective, to say one is right and one is wrong means that you're saying that your opinion of the matter is really the only one that matters, which is the most contradicting thing of all.

I think it's a lot of fun to talk and compare our favourite and inpired characters. But let's be honest with ouselves. No one wants to talk about these things with a "I'm right, you're wrong" kind of guy. Because in the end, whether it's Death Battle, Cartoon Fight Club, you, me, the wiki's jerk of the month, or this WOG I heard about, no one is ever wrong.

But in the worst case scenario, it's perfectly fine to think that you yourself might have been wrong. I've been wrong on many things, and trust me, it's not that bad of a feeling.