Talk:Nightmare VS Guts/@comment-68.192.226.49-20150320204348/@comment-216.232.23.22-20150321004524

Nightmare might win because Guts has no way to completely kill Soul Edge. No Soul Edge, No Nightmare.

In SCV, Nightmare was actually weaker due to the fact Soul Edge was fragmented, which meant his power was separated and scattered. Soul Edge was destroyed by Soul Calibur. Even though there's no other moments in the game where Soul Edge was destroyed by normal weapons, and most of the characters use Soul Calibur to kill it, it's safe to assume that Soul Edge and Soul Calibur are the only ones that can destroy each other.

Guts may have killed demons (Apostles) similar to Nightmare in terms of cosmetics, but he's just an extremely strong human with enhanced human performance via his armor.

In short, Guts will put up a fight with his all, but Nightmare himself will outlast Guts.