Talk:Luigi vs. Tails/@comment-24.60.32.185-20140504194811/@comment-16919137-20140603195635

For now, lets analyze all of the feats and see who wins the feat contest:

Speed: Tails by far. Do I need to explain for this one?

Strength: Comparing strength, dragging 10 tons is impressive. But Luigi also effortlessly destroyed castles, whether it was with his feet, hammer, or just picking it up with his own hands and kicking it away. Plus, as stated, he lifted the 30 ton King Bomb Omb.

Oh, and that Radish thing.... Super Mario Bros 2/USA was a non-cannon dream. Luigi takes the strength category.

Weapons/Armor: Again, Luigi takes it. His Poltergust could suck up the Shield bot, Medi bot, and Grappling Ring, due to their small size and overall lightness. The Poltergust could also be used to suck up and shoot Tail's Bombs right back at him. Oh, and the Negative Zone, Tails would be virtually helpless, due to the Negative Zone either putting Tails to sleep or making him dizzy. Basically, for versatility. And the Vanish Power Flower grants him invincibility.

Intelligence: Tails.

Durability: Luigi. He can survive a fall of virtually any height, is able to, somehow, breath underwater and space. Not to mention he has survived being hit indefinite times by a hammer, being shot out of a cannon, and even survived a supernova.

How well they can fight without their Player 1's: Both tend to rely on their superiors, but who fights better without them? Luigi does. Tails, while having fought on his own on occasion, tends to fight better on Sonic's side. Luigi has held his own on multiple occasions, including Mario is Missing, Luigi's Mansion 1 and 2, Super Mario 64 DS, etc.

Who is affected more by their weaknesses: Lets go over the list:

Luigi: Clumsy, Cowardly, Fear of Ghosts, Bad traction.

Tails: Lightning Fear, Lack of Self-Confidence, Can only fly for so long, Ghost fear.

Tails isn't affected as much by his weaknesses, so he gets the point here.

Combat Experience: Luigi. He has been on more adventures, and is 15 years older than Tails.

Overall: This is one of the closer Death Battles. However, Luigi takes it 7-3. Luigi is just better is most categories. Sure, Tails has speed and intelligence, with less exploitable weaknesses, but really, he is triumphed in every other category.

Also, watch this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RwwBu9bGs-M