Board Thread:VS Debates/@comment-28834876-20160929133821/@comment-5898946-20170212220722

Amy wins.

Two major reasons:

First and foremost, she outspeeds Peach. By a lot. Peach can only hit Amy if she gets lucky.

Second, Amy has the ability to cloak herself. All she needs to do is cloak, then smash Peach's skull in with her hammer.